Kindle vs. iPad: Fair Comparison?

It is truly amusing to hear and read what Kindle fans have to say about the iPad and vice versa. Hardcore Kindle fans seem unwilling to give Apple iPad any credit and do not even consider the device a true e-reader. iPad fans consider Kindle a one trick pony device that is not only overpriced but incapable of delivering a fraction of what iPad brings to the table. In reality, both devices have their advantages and disadvantages and are not exactly clones of each other. Consumer Reports’ piece on iPad vs. Kindle demonstrates some of those fundamental differences:

If you are lucky enough to own both devices, you would agree that the reading experience on an iPad is very much different than what you get on a Kindle. Kindle is much easier on the eyes and can be used outdoors without readers having to deal with sun glare. At the same time, you can not read on your Kindle in a dark room without a decent book light. Apple iPad works the exact opposite way.

Price is going to play a big factor whether people go with the Kindle or the iPad in the near future. At the moment, Amazon Kindle is a bit overpriced. There is simply no reason Amazon is asking for $260 for Kindle when it should be working on bringing its price to somewhere under $200. Considering that iPad can read B&N and Amazon books (using apps), it is an attractive choice for those who want to get the best out of both stores. Not everyone is going to want to pick up a Kindle or a Nook just because they use E-ink technology. Amazon and B&N will need to lower their prices and innovate to stay relevant. From what we have heard, they may be in the process of doing that already.

Your thoughts: iPad vs. Kindle – which one is better in your opinion?